|
When
company owners go
searching for funding,
they need to ask the
right questions of
potential investors.
Entrepreneurs tend to
prepare themselves for
investors’ questions,
but need to make some
poignant inquiries of
their own.
When
Russell Dodd of Nomad
Technologies in the
mid-Atlantic region
launched his first round
of investment recently,
he found plenty of
potential investors
willing to talk and
willing to move into the
due diligence stage.
However, to Dodd’s
surprise, some companies
were asking hefty
application fees and
asking him to divulge
specific information
about patented software
and business practices.
Dodd expected fees, but
questioned handing over
his software to a
potential investor he
spoke to on the phone
only a couple times.
While most potential
investors are honest,
Dodd knew of a few
instances when company
secrets were stolen in
scams.
“We
have had some success in
talking to potential
investors and have had
several companies
interested in moving
into the due-diligence
stage of investment.
However, some of the
companies are asking for
outrageous fees and
other application
fees,” Dodd says.
“We understand these
fees but do not feel
comfortable in taking
the next step in fear
they might try and steal
our software or idea. We
have heard some pretty
bad stories in respect
to scams of this sort.
Although, we do have a
patent for our software
and business method, we
still do not want to
just hand our software
to someone we spoke to
on the phone a couple
times.”
Dodd’s
concerns are real and a
common challenge for
every young company that
steps into the funding
arena. The bottom line
is for self-protection
company owners need to
do their due-diligence
before throwing open the
most intimate details of
their businesses,
software or intellectual
property.
1. Perform due
diligence yourself:
You can perform a
routine credit
investigation for a very
modest sum. There are
plenty of due diligence
and investigative firms
that offer these
services, often for less
than $100, according to
Mike Roer, Executive
Director of the
Connecticut Venture
Group, a professional
organization committed
to connecting leading
Venture Investments
professionals with
high-growth emerging
companies in
Connecticut.
Investigation firms can
also check with the
local police for a
criminal record.
Roer says: “My
defenses always go up
when I hear ‘fees.’
This may be legit, or
the "investor"
merely wants to sell you
a package of fund
raising services. I have
heard prices quoted of
$1000 to $25,000. I
would ask the investor
point blank if he can
provide the cash you
need or if he is merely
going to source the
funds for you as a
broker. Some brokers
also invest a token
amount of around
$50,000. I compare this
to selling a house. You
can try to do it
yourself and save the
fees, or retain an agent
who knows the ropes and
pay fees plus a
percentage.
Try to sell the equity
interest yourself first.
Some investors assume
you do not have a choice
offering if you need a
broker to hawk it.
2. Ask for references.
For example, check with
CEO's of other companies
to whom an investor has
committed funds.
Reputable investors are
proud of their portfolio
companies and often list
them on their web sites.
Then, call the CEOs and
ask about their
experiences.
3. Get a lawyer now.
You'll need one
eventually anyway. Spend
a half hour reviewing
the situation now.
You can probably find
someone to provide this
upfront consultation
free.
4. Protect
Intellectual Property:
Regarding software and
inventions, do no turn
it over. Invite
legitimate investors to
see a demonstration. No
one needs to know how it
works, only what it will
do. There is a risk of
the idea being stolen.
There is also the risk
of someone else thinking
of it independently.
Speed, therefore, is of
the essence. This is why
you are considering
venture capital in the
first place.
John
Andres, former
Chief Patent Counsel at
US Surgical and Patent
Counsel at Priceline.com,
believes that the
intellectual property
field is complex, and
counsel fees are well
worth the expense in the
long run.
“Don’t let intellectual property sit around and collect
dust,” Andres says.
“Get good advice early
and lock up what gives
you an edge in the
market and can create
valuation for your
company.”
5.
Join a Venture
Association where
you will meet investors,
lawyers, and other CEOs
at your stage. Check
your local chamber of
commerce or state
department of economic
development for the
non-profit nearest you.
“A
compromise might be to
contact investors you
know to be reputable,
rather than reveal
inside information to
someone who seeks you
out a bit too
eagerly,” Roer says.
“Also, check out
portfolio companies.
Does the investor have
an interest in a
potential competitor? If
so, you may want to
avoid that contact.
However, if the investor
has an interest in a
firm that is a potential
supplier or customer, it
could be a perfect fit.
Eventually, you will
have to trust someone.
The trick is picking the
right one.”
|